Value ranking

The most valuable Blastoise cards, ranked.

Blastoise has always run just behind Charizard in the starter pecking order, and its cards follow the same pattern: a step below the fire lizard, but with real value of its own. The Base Set holo leads, and a modern Special Illustration Rare gives it a fresh chase. This ranks the Blastoise cards worth real money.

Base Set Blastoise holo

Blastoise tracks Charizard in collector pull and trails it in price, the pattern for the whole starter trio. Its most valuable card is the Base Set holo, with modern ex chases and vintage Dark and e-Card prints behind it. This ranks the top Blastoise cards by value.

PSA 10 1st Edition: five figures
Base Set Blastoise holo

The most valuable Blastoise card by a wide margin. The Base Set Blastoise is the water half of the original holo trio, and a 1st Edition copy in PSA 10 has cleared the five figures. Centering on the right border is the usual grade-killer, where the holo registration ran inconsistent. One note for buyers: a separate Galaxy Star presentation Blastoise exists and has sold for hundreds of thousands, but it is a different object from the card in packs.

Blastoise ex Special Illustration Rare from 151

The modern Blastoise chase. The 151 Special Illustration Rare puts Blastoise in a full-art alternate scene, and it sits in the starter trio of SIRs alongside Charizard and Venusaur. It trades behind the Charizard but level with Venusaur, the same hierarchy the starters have followed since 1999, and it is the way modern collectors own a chase Blastoise.

PSA 10 1st Edition: four figures
Dark Blastoise from Team Rocket

A vintage Team Rocket holo that rides the same starter nostalgia as the Base Set card. Dark Blastoise is one of the stronger secondary Dark holos, carried by the Blastoise following, and it gives collectors a four-figure vintage Blastoise below the Base Set print. High grades hold up well thanks to the loyal starter fanbase.

PSA 10: high three figures
Blastoise holo from Expedition

The e-Card era Blastoise, and an underrated vintage holo. The Expedition Blastoise is harder to find in high grade than its price suggests, because the glossy e-Card surface scratches easily. For a collector who wants an early-2000s Blastoise holo that is not the Base Set card, it is the standout option.

Why Blastoise lives in Charizard’s shadow

Blastoise has everything going for it except being Charizard. It is a beloved starter with strong cards in every era, but the fire lizard absorbs the cultural attention that drives the very top of the market. The practical effect is that Blastoise cards offer a lot of the same nostalgia at a lower price, which makes them appealing to collectors who love the design and do not want to pay the Charizard premium. The Base Set holo is the cornerstone, and the modern SIR keeps a fresh chase alive.

Common questions

What is the most valuable Blastoise card?
The Base Set Blastoise, card 2, well ahead of everything else. A 1st Edition copy in PSA 10 has cleared the five figures. The 151 Special Illustration Rare is the most valuable modern Blastoise.
What is the Galaxy Star Blastoise?
It is a rare 1998 presentation prototype Blastoise, not a tournament-legal card, that has sold for hundreds of thousands at auction. It is a different object from the standard Base Set Blastoise, though headlines often blur the two.
Is Blastoise worth less than Charizard?
Yes, in every era. Blastoise tracks Charizard in collector demand but trades well below it, because Charizard carries the cultural weight that drives the top of the market. That makes Blastoise a more affordable way to own the same nostalgia.
Keep reading

Apply this to your binder.

Binder organizes your collection with the variants and grade context this guide covers. Free on iPhone.